Best Sellers

Filter by
24 PRODUCTS
Back

  • DEFAULT
  • NEWEST FIRST
  • PRICE LOW TO HIGH
  • PRICE HIGH TO LOW
24 PRODUCTS
best sellersentertaining
favourites favourites selected Coperthwaite Coperthwaite hover
Coperthwaite
$33

Our most local farmstead cheesemaker, Churchtown Dairy, makes these delicious...

best sellers
favourites favourites selected Bru XL Bru XL hover
Bru XL
$13.50

Made in the Netherlands using a traditional Gouda recipe, these wheels are ag...

best sellers
favourites favourites selected Cabot Clothbound Cheddar Cabot Clothbound Cheddar hover
Cabot Clothbound Cheddar
$17.50

Modeled after a traditional English cheddar, wheels are wrapped in muslin, th...

best sellers
favourites favourites selected Alp Blossom Alp Blossom hover
Alp Blossom
$20

Wheels are made with incredibly rich, unskimmed milk from the Allgäu region o...

best sellersfemale producer
favourites favourites selected 1605 Manchego 1605 Manchego hover
1605 Manchego
$20

The epitome of a farmstead Manchego, 1605 Manchego is produced as it would ha...

best sellersstaff picks
favourites favourites selected Cravero Parmigiano Reggiano Cravero Parmigiano Reggiano hover
Cravero Parmigiano Reg...
$19

Simply put, this is the best Parmigiano in existence. Incredibly snackable, e...

best sellers
favourites favourites selected Camembert Fermier Camembert Fermier hover
Camembert Fermier
$20

Farmstead versions of this French classic are increasingly hard to find, espc...

best sellers
favourites favourites selected Brabander Gouda Brabander Gouda hover
Brabander Gouda
$19

A sweet and rich goat's milk gouda, made with milk from a handful of small fa...

best sellersentertaining
favourites favourites selected Jake's Gouda Jake's Gouda hover
Jake's Gouda
$13.50

A traditional Dutch-style aged gouda, crafted in upstate NY. Made with raw co...

best sellers
favourites favourites selected Shelburne 2 Year Cheddar Shelburne 2 Year Cheddar hover
Shelburne 2 Year Cheddar
$14

A classic New England cheddar, made with milk from the cows at Shelburne's ow...

best sellers
favourites favourites selected Salsiccia Stagionata Salsiccia Stagionata hover
Salsiccia Stagionata
$16

A traditional salame, just a little salt, pepper, garlic and red wine. A perf...

best sellers
favourites favourites selected Finocchietta Finocchietta hover
Finocchietta
$25

Cured pork salame with delicate flavors of fennel and red wine

best sellers
favourites favourites selected Talbott & Arding Fruit and Nut Loaf - 3 pack Talbott & Arding Fruit and Nut Loaf - 3 pack hover
Talbott & Arding Fruit...
$75

Three of our famous fruit and nut loaves. Chock-full of organic fruit and nut...

best sellers
favourites favourites selected Talbott & Arding Fruit and Nut Loaf Talbott & Arding Fruit and Nut Loaf hover
Talbott & Arding Fruit...
$26

A Talbott & Arding classic and longstanding favorite from our beloved Pas...

best sellers
favourites favourites selected Talbott & Arding Fig Bars Talbott & Arding Fig Bars hover
Talbott & Arding Fig Bars
$9

"My father, who really loved Fig Newtons, would have gone crazy for the homem...

best sellers
favourites favourites selected Talbott & Arding  Caraway Rye Crackers Talbott & Arding  Caraway Rye Crackers hover
Talbott & Arding Cara...
$11

Made with whole grain rye flour from Farmer Ground in Trumansburg, brushed wi...

Showing 16 of 24